While they may have dished out gongs to the likes of Paolo Nutini and The Feeling in recent years, the songwriting and composing figureheads who judge The Ivor Novello Awards tend to be an astute bunch. Where else this year might you expect to see a light being shone on the tunesmithery of Villagers, Everything Everything, Foals and Jon Hopkins? And what other ceremony has ever given Ash’s Tim Wheeler - winner of best contemporary song in 2002 for the peerless ‘Shining Light' - the recognition he deserves?
The Ivors also famously gave warehouse worker Nick Hemming a break a couple of years ago when they made The Leisure Society frontman the first self-published nominee in the ‘best song musically and lyrically’ category in the awards’ 54-year history. We had spent the weeks leading up to that nomination telling anyone who'd listen about the “lovingly crafted, tender folk record” that was/is The Sleeper, the London/Brighton octet's debut LP; and those judges must have heard us, because lo and behold back they came last year to put Hemming’s name forward once more, this time for another song taken from that same 2009 album. Fast-forward another twelve months, and it’s a wonder they didn’t encourage the Burton-Upon-Trent native to bring forward the release of his band's follow-up, because they could comfortably fill a couple of categories this year with the exquisite collection that makes up Into The Murky Water.
While Hemming and fellow Staffordshire exile Christian Hardy were ably assisted by friends from Brighton’s Willkommen Collective last time out, the same six-strong backing have more of a role here giving ...Murky Water a more cohesive feel throughout and allowing the songs to achieve their full potential. This strength in depth is exploited from the word go, as xylophone, strings and flute all make an appearance before a single word has been sung on the album’s eponymous opening number.
As much as it represents a confident progression, this is a record that still has much in common with its predecessor: Hemming’s lyrics remain predominantly sombre in tone - perhaps even more so than previously, in fact - and they’re no less affecting than before (witness ‘The Hungry Years’' blinding “You squeezed me like a comfort blanket / That keeps you warm but will hold you back...”, a personal favourite line at the time of writing). While the mood may be downbeat, however, the melodies are anything but: sprightly lead single ‘This Phantom Life’, surefire follow-up ‘You Could Keep Me Talking’ and The Divine Comedy-referencing ‘Better Written Off (Than Written Down)’ are summer-soundtrackers one and all.
But just as ‘The Last of The Melting Snow’ calmly stole the show on album number one, it’s the more subdued moments that linger longest here: ‘I Will Always Be An Amateur’ - written as Hemming’s days of wrapping fabric in a furniture warehouse were coming to an end - is a particularly well-observed five-and-a-half minutes of music. Elsewhere, The 'Society's clever juxtaposition of uniquely British-sounding songs and influences that are clearly drawn from modern American greats like Grizzly Bear and Sufjan Stevens reaches a new high-water mark during the intro to (possibly ironically-titled) album-closer 'Just Like The Knife'.
An elegantly arresting piece of work, Into The Murky Water is the kind of fiercely strong sophomore record that not only convinces the listener of a band's consistency and worth, but also hints at a group who are slowly but surely starting to leave their peers for dust. As The Leisure Society prove here, it's always the quiet ones you've got to keep an eye on.